| 2010 | ||
| 1 | Michael Woepse | (Mater Dei, Santa Ana, California) |
| 2 | Paul Malquist | (Gainesville, Georgia) |
| 3 | *Andrew Irwin | (Mt. Ida, Arkansas) |
| 4 | Logan Pflibsen | (Township, Streator, Illinois) |
| 5 | *JJ Juilfs | (Sheldon, Eugene, Oregon) |
| 2011 | ||
| 1 | Andrew Irwin | (Mt. Ida, Arkansas) |
| 2 | *Jacob Blankenship | (Lincoln, Gahanna, Ohio) |
| 3 | JJ Juilfs | (Sheldon, Eugene, Oregon) |
| 4 | Joseph Uhle | (Olentangy Liberty, Powell, Ohio) |
| 5 | *Reese Watson | (Spring, Texas) |
| 2012 | ||
| 1 | Shawn Barber’ | (Park, Kingwood, Texas) |
| 2 | Jacob Blankenship | (Lincoln, Gahanna, Ohio) |
| 3 | Dylan Bell | (Alvarado, Texas) |
| 4 | Reese Watson | (Spring, Texas) |
| 5 | Garrett Starkey | (Basha, Chandler, Arizona) |
| 2013 | ||
| 1 | Daven Murphree | (Harmony, Big Sandy, Texas) |
| 2 | Dylan Duvio | (Curtis, River Ridge, Louisiana) |
| 3 | *Devin King | (Sumner, Kentwood, Louisiana) |
| 4 | Cole Walsh | (Brophy, Phoenix, Arizona) |
| 5 | Scott Marshall | (Desert Vista, Phoenix, Arizona) |
